AI news, articles and features | New ̹½ֱ²¥ /topic/ai/ Science news and science articles from New ̹½ֱ²¥ Tue, 17 Nov 2026 16:41:31 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0.8 242057827 Just nine countries back pledge to tackle AI’s environmental footprint /article/2599357-just-nine-countries-back-pledge-to-tackle-ais-environmental-footprint/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Tue, 17 Nov 2026 13:56:50 +0000 /article/2599357-auto-draft/
The COP31 presidency hopes countries will commit to reducing the environmental impact of AI
UN Climate Change/Kiara Worth

Only nine countries have signed an international pledge to make AI greener, despite warnings at the COP31 climate summit that the technology’s growing energy demands threaten climate goals.

The Antalya Artificial Intelligence Pledge was launched on 16 November at the summit in Turkey. Developed by the summit’s presidency and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), it intends to make AI more sustainable by encouraging cleaner energy use, more efficient data centres and greater transparency about the technology’s environmental footprint.

“AI and other frontier technologies are a double-edged sword,” said Simon Stiell, the executive secretary of UN Climate Change, at a press conference on 16 November. “The task ahead is to blunt their dangerous edges, sharpen their catalytic ones and put these technologies responsibly to work.”

But an independent analyst researching AI’s climate impacts, questions that analogy. He says it conflates traditional machine learning, already used in applications such as weather forecasting, with energy-intensive generative AI. “You don’t need to have a giant, energy-hungry generative AI chatbot if you want to have better wind forecasting for a wind power developer,” he says.

The initiative comes as AI’s rapid expansion is placing growing pressure on electricity grids. According to the International Energy Agency, electricity consumption from AI-focused data centres in 2025.

Joshi says there is little evidence that technology companies are building enough renewable energy capacity to meet this growing demand. Even companies that have invested heavily in renewables, such as Amazon and Google, are increasingly turning to fossil fuels to support their rapid expansion, he says.

The only countries to have so far are Andorra, Brazil, Colombia, Luxembourg, Sierra Leone, Somalia, South Korea, Turkey and Uganda.

The pledge is voluntary, with no binding targets for cutting emissions or reducing energy consumption. It sets out four areas for action, including increasing the use of low- and zero-emission energy to power AI infrastructure, improving energy and water efficiency, and measuring the environmental impacts of AI systems. It also calls for greater financial and technical support to help developing countries use AI to tackle climate change.

However, the agreement leaves considerable room for interpretation. The call for using “low- and zero-emission energy”, for example, allows continued reliance on fossil gas rather than committing to renewable electricity.

Countries can also choose additional commitments, such as requiring AI companies to disclose their energy consumption and environmental impacts, or introducing sustainability requirements for data centres.

“I’m surprised that more countries haven’t signed up, given the pledge’s limited demands,” says Joshi. “It’s not a pledge that really strikes at the heart of the problem.” He argues that voluntary promises are unlikely to be sufficient without restrictions on the expansion of data centres and stronger AI regulation.

COP31 President Murat Kurum defended the initiative, saying the rapid growth of AI must be “powered and deployed responsibly, and used for the benefit of climate actions”. The ITU says progress on the pledge will be reviewed at annual UN climate summits until 2030, starting at COP32 next year.

Joshi fears the pledge could provide cover for continued expansion via fossil fuel sources. “I think we’re going to be going into an era of a return to greenwashing, a return to sort of empty promises,” he says. “What we really need is stronger and stricter regulation.”

]]>
2599357
How I used evidence and imagination to write an account of the world in 2096 /article/2598686-how-i-used-evidence-and-imagination-to-write-an-account-of-the-world-in-2096/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Mon, 16 Nov 2026 17:00:00 +0000 /article/2598686-auto-draft/
Fatih Aktas/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

How do you invent the future? This isn’t a question that I had ever had to consider until I set out to imagine what the world would be like in 70 years’ time for New ̹½ֱ²¥’s 70th anniversary. As a lifelong sci-fi nerd, I have read and watched loads of material that could have served as inspiration. But this being New ̹½ֱ²¥, I wanted to make sure that I was as grounded in real science and technology as possible – while acknowledging that no prediction of the future is ever correct.

I began by asking my colleagues on the magazine for their ideas about the future and then attempted to corral this sci-fi smorgasbord into something resembling an outline of a self-consistent narrative. Part of the problem in imagining many different futures is that they contradict themselves – you can’t have the war-torn AI dystopia of Terminator alongside the utopia of Star Trek.

I wanted both hope and realism in my future, so I decided to look at how the scientific literature handles the end of the century. One of the most obvious forecasts is for climate change, where we have a pretty good idea about what might happen in 2096, under a range of scenarios, because it all boils down to atmospheric physics that we can model. Of course, which of these scenarios we end up with is all too dependent on human politics, so the science alone couldn’t guide me. I also turned to population projections, which, for the most part, are locked in based on current population trends. The idea that the end of the century will be the first time we are living in a world of falling populations became a fascinating strand in the final piece.

The biggest problem I faced was how to deal with AI. I am not confident making predictions on this topic even just a few years in advance – as I’ve written previously, my views on AI have evolved between the release of ChatGPT in 2022 and now, so how could I possibly predict what would happen by the time we got to 2096? Furthermore, there was a risk that AI could come to dominate the piece, crowding out everything else. There is a graph I often think about, under the headline “AI could end scarcity, end humanity – or boost [GDP] growth by 0.2 percentage points”. I knew that, to preserve any meaningful narrative, I had to restrict AI to this boring middle option, so I invented an AI-fuelled financial crisis that would see us place limits on the technology. I have no idea if such an event is likely to happen, but it seems to me to be the only way to preserve a future that remains comprehensible to us today.

I spoke to dozens of experts to help inform this piece, expecting them to contradict each other in ways that were both helpful and confounding, and they did. But what I found most interesting is how little interdisciplinary forecasting there is across science. For example, attempts to predict future public health trends are only just starting to consider how climate change will interact with the diseases and medical conditions we face. Meanwhile, many of the people I spoke to hadn’t deeply considered how AI would affect the evolution of their chosen discipline.

In weaving all this together, one of the most surprising things I arrived at was the idea of expanding the legal concept of personhood. Looking at how our attitudes towards both animals and artificial intelligence are changing today, it seemed to me that this was a possibility, so I created the International Treaty on Non-Human Personhood. Its existence in the story had a number of interesting downstream effects, and I kept finding different ways for non-human people to influence the world. Again, this is a big bet, but I think not an unreasonable one.

One thing I couldn’t escape from in writing this piece is the idea that I and probably all of the people I interviewed won’t be around to see what comes to pass. I would be 110 years old in 2096 – not impossible, especially given the advances in medicine I describe in the piece, but still unlikely. In some ways, 70 years from now is the perfect amount of time to forecast the future, being just outside most adults’ expected lifespan. We can never know what will really happen – we can only imagine.

70 years of New ̹½ֱ²¥

This article is part of a special series commemorating our 70th anniversary, featuring contributions from our most loyal readers and a few Nobel prize winners.

]]>
2598686
This is what the world will be like in 2096: A special report from the future /article/2597572-this-is-what-the-world-will-be-like-in-2096-a-special-report-from-the-future/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Mon, 16 Nov 2026 16:00:00 +0000 /article/2597572-auto-draft/ 2597572 How Nvidia became so crucial to the AI boom /article/2598755-how-nvidia-became-so-crucial-to-the-ai-boom/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Thu, 12 Nov 2026 15:49:12 +0000 /article/2598755-auto-draft/ 2598755 Are we outsourcing our thinking to AI – and how much should we worry? /article/2597838-are-we-outsourcing-our-thinking-to-ai-and-how-much-should-we-worry/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Wed, 11 Nov 2026 18:00:00 +0000 /article/2597838-losing-touch/ 2597838 Google shouldn’t be pressuring schools to use its AI /article/2597761-google-shouldnt-be-pressuring-schools-to-use-its-ai/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Thu, 05 Nov 2026 16:46:46 +0000 /article/2597761-auto-draft/
Should children use AI in school?
AnnaStills/Shutterstock

When I was at school, a new technology launched in the form of a magic box that could answer any question you wanted. It was called Google, and my teachers cautioned that we shouldn’t trust everything it spat out, because anyone could put anything on the internet. Three decades later, history is repeating – with a twist. Schools are now begging Google to allow students to access its search engine, but the tech giant says that is only possible if teachers also accept a new kind of magic box, AI.

Google is far more integrated into education than it was in my day, with its Classroom and Workspace products providing teachers and students with a range of tools from email to lesson planning. More recently, Google has incorporated its Gemini AI chatbot into Classroom, to the chagrin of some US school districts that want to be able to decide whether or not students have access to AI. Sure, said Google, you can switch off AI, but then you lose search. “Search and AI are deeply integrated,” Google’s Chris Phillips .

At first, I thought this must be a misunderstanding about what we call AI. For most people today, AI means a large language model (LLM) of the type that powers Gemini or ChatGPT. But Google’s search engine has long used AI in the historical sense of machine learning, starting in 2015 that helped relate words to concepts in order to produce search results. The AI Overviews you often see at the top of a search today, which launched in 2024, are the only part of the search results produced by Gemini.

Surely, I thought, what’s happening here is that school districts saying “no AI” simply mean no AI Overviews, while Google is quite reasonably saying it isn’t possible to rip out elements of its search engine that have been operating for over a decade in order to comply with a strict “no AI” request. This can easily be solved by making sure everyone is talking about the same thing, right?

Wrong. Google really is presenting schools with an all-or-nothing choice. “If a school is not comfortable with that and simply wants AI off, then they have the choice to not have search on at all,” Phillips told . This is a product decision, not a technical one. AI Overviews do not appear on every search, and they can be disabled for every search by . Google could surely provide schools with this option, if it wished. When asked to comment, a Google spokesperson sent New ̹½ֱ²¥ a link to with its Gemini product.

We have seen a tech giant use this playbook before. Around the same time that Google was launching its young, upstart search engine in the late 1990s, Microsoft was facing legal action for forcing people to install the Internet Explorer (IE) browser as part of its Windows operating system, in an effort to fight off competitor browsers. At the time, for IE were an “integral part” of Windows and could not be removed “without impairing the performance of the operating system”. In 2001, a US court ruled that this integration served to illegally maintain a monopoly, and Microsoft was obliged to make other browsers more accessible. By 2010, , following a European Commission ruling.

There is no suggestion that Google is doing anything illegal in its approach to schools, although the company is , and commentators have accused it of exploiting that monopoly. “Google is trying to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools”, . Following the backlash, that for schools, Gemini and search will be off by default and schools can choose to turn on either at their discretion. That doesn’t actually address the issue of having search without AI Overviews, however.

Ultimately, it will probably be for the courts to decide whether Google should be made to offer search without AI, but I am more interested in the question of how and when children should begin to use AI. Google has a 90 per cent market share in search, so it would be naive to think that children aren’t being exposed to AI Overviews, even if they do end up banned in schools. Personally, I know that AI Overviews can be heavily flawed and provide incorrect information, and yet I still find it hard to ignore them at the top of my search results, even while knowing that I should be clicking links to provide websites with revenue if I want them to continue existing.

Research on how LLMs affect learning is still in early days, but the evidence we have is worrying. found that people who used an LLM summary rather than a list of links gained a shallower understanding of a topic, seemingly because having the results predigested by an AI required less cognitive effort. in China found that allowing them to use AI drastically improved homework performance, but saw exam results fall – suggesting that the children were letting AI do their homework for them without really learning anything.

Google’s answer to these concerns is its Guided Learning product, which it is . It says the system will pick up when children are looking for help with homework, and walk them through it step by step, rather than simply providing an answer. , Google says this approach provided more than a year of typical learning progress in just eight weeks.

In principle, I am not against the use of AI in schools – it is a modern, useful technology that will surely be part of students’ lives in the future, and they should learn to understand it just as I learned the pros and cons of using Google back in the 90s. The question of how to handle homework assignments in the age of AI, when an essay can be produced in seconds, is thorny and ongoing. One option is to simply scrap homework and require more in-classroom testing, but if Google gets its way and AI ends up being unavoidable there as well, it seems like teachers will have little control. That, to me, is the most objectionable point, as it should not be down to tech giants to set education policy.

Further AI reading

  • A YouTuber has used AI to analyse inaudible (to humans) sounds from aircraft in the background of a video, and then cross-reference that with public flight data to . It is pretty extraordinary, and I have seen other people replicating the technique, but I would be interested to see a proper study on just how powerful this is.
  • , demonstrating just how reliant the AI company has become on its own products. There are a few caveats to that – Anthropic is obviously not paying itself retail prices, and many of its employees are remunerated with stock options in addition to salaries. Nevertheless, Anthropic has seen its internal use rocket this year, up in September by a factor of 250 compared with January.
  • The UK’s National Cyber Security Centre has warned that “AI-cyber” (a horrible phrase, meaning AI-powered cyberattacks) will . I entirely agree – the ability of the latest AI models to find security holes in software is astounding, and it seems like the only way to defend against it is yet more AI.
]]>
2597761
The most important part of AI chatbots is being ignored /article/2596083-the-most-important-part-of-ai-chatbots-is-being-ignored/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Wed, 28 Oct 2026 09:00:00 +0000 /article/2596083-auto-draft/
AI chatbots have several layers we don’t always think about
Jaap Arriens/NurPhoto via Getty Images

ChatGPT was never meant to start a revolution. When it launched in November 2022, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman called it “an early demo” and expectations were low. Personally, my initial reaction was that it seemed no more capable than previous large language models (LLMs) OpenAI had released; it just had a nicer interface. Obviously, I was wrong to dismiss the importance of the interface, but in 2026 I think most people who use AI are making a similar mistake without even realising it. What you think of as ChatGPT or Claude or any other chatbot from a big AI brand is actually many pieces of software wrapped into one, and we are ignoring the most important: the harness.

To understand what a harness is and how it works, it helps to break down the multiple things we call ChatGPT. At the very bottom is the LLM, currently a version of GPT-6, but this gets switched out when OpenAI releases new model families. LLMs do one thing: given a string of text, they predict the most likely next characters. OpenAI’s first model, GPT-1, was released in 2018 as a piece of software that you had to download and run on your computer through a terminal, the text-based interface to a computer that most of us avoid. The same was true of GPT-2 in 2019, until an independent software developer called Adam King created Talk to Transformer, a now-defunct website that allowed you to enter a prompt and get a GPT-2 response in return. Back-and-forth chat wasn’t possible, but this was an early example of an interface, in this case a website, sitting on top of a model.

In 2020, OpenAI released GPT-3 and, for the first time, allowed people to access it through an application programming interface (API), its first commercial product. APIs are a standard way for one computer to communicate with another – for example, Google has a Google Maps API that lets a piece of software send a request for location data. OpenAI’s API let anyone create software that could plug in to GPT-3. At the time, I played with a few of these and found them interesting but clunky – the text they produced was often incorrect or flawed in some way, though it was cool that this level of text generation was even possible. This was essentially still a time of “raw” LLM output, with no guard rails – if you asked GPT-3 to .

That changed with the release of GPT-3.5 and, at the same time, ChatGPT, which was first called “Chat with GPT-3.5” until a last-minute name change. That original name reveals the way OpenAI saw ChatGPT, as simply an interface to a model, and this explains my reaction as well – the results I got from playing with ChatGPT seemed to be similar to GPT-3, just easier to use.

Actually, there was a crucial difference. With GPT-3.5, OpenAI had attempted to install guard rails that would prevent the model from producing text it deemed harmful, with software that would screen inputs and outputs. These didn’t work very well – you could get around them by , for example – but this was the beginning of a move away from raw LLMs to ones mediated by a harness sitting between the model and the interface.

Today, the ChatGPT product, whether that’s the app on your phone or the website, has an extensive harness that is mostly hidden from the user. It allows the model to do things like search the internet, read documents, or “reason”, meaning to continuously prompt itself through a “chain of thought” to produce better results. OpenAI also has another, more complex harness for its models, called Codex, which allows the LLM to more directly control a computer and so is particularly useful for writing computer code.

Why does any of this matter? Well, the dirty secret of the big AI firms is that their best models are, to some extent, interchangeable. The technology behind an OpenAI GPT model, a generative pre-trained transformer, is the same as the one used by Anthropic, Google or any other AI company. There are important differences in the data and computing power used to train these models, but generally they are all headed in the same direction, which is why the companies are constantly racing to claim the crown of “best” model before another one takes its place.

What really makes the difference is the harness. To illustrate this, I gave the same prompt – “Who am I?” – to the same model, GPT-6, in three different ways. Via API, I got a response beginning: “I don’t know your identify from this chat.” From chatgpt.com, without being logged in, I got a response that started “That’s a big question. 🙂”. When logged in to my personal account, the response began “You’re Jacob Aron, a senior editor at New ̹½ֱ²¥, with a strong interest in mathematics, science, technology and the limits of what we can actually know.”

But the harness matters much more than simply knowing a few facts about the user. In the ARC-AGI test, considered to be one of the leading measures of model “intelligence”, models are tested using either a . The difference is remarkable – for GPT-6 Astra, OpenAI’s leading public model, when using the provider adapter harness rather than the standard one. For an earlier model, GPT-5.6 Sol, OpenAI found that .

If harnesses are so important, why don’t we talk about them more often? Why don’t AI firms shout about their new harness, rather than just their latest model? I think there are a few reasons. The first is simply that they are complicated and technical – I have taken a whole article to explain them – and your average chatbot user doesn’t really need to know about it. But the second is that they are, in a way, boring. The cost of training a leading LLM is approaching $1 billion, a Herculean effort that requires number crunching across a vast army of computer processors. Once LLMs are trained, we still don’t really know exactly how they produce the results that they do, providing an air of mystery. Harnesses, on the other hand, are just ordinary software, lines of code written by humans that anyone can read.

But here is where it gets really interesting. If a harness is just code, can an AI write and improve its own harness? That is currently an open research question, both inside the AI firms and for academics. For example, in a paper , one research team tested models by identifying repeated failures and proposing tweaks to their harnesses that would address the failures, seeing improvements of around 10 to 40 percentage points on benchmarks. This is why I think we are going to be hearing much more about harnesses in the near future. If the goal of the AI firms is recursive self-improvement – an AI that can build a better AI – then the harness, not the model, could be the key to achieving it.

Further AI reading:

  • OpenAI appears to have overturned a big assumption in computer science, as part of a release that saw new results in maths and physics as well. Interestingly, it is taking a slightly different approach for each of them . For the maths result, related to a problem about spinning a needle, OpenAI has released the AI output in full. It is doing the same for the computer science result, a refutation of a conjecture called the exponential time hypothesis, while also funding a conference to discuss it. The physics result is being held back until it is reviewed by external experts. It seems like OpenAI is still trying to figure out what to do about its models stepping on academics’ toes.
  • Anthropic has ahead of a planned initial public offering (IPO) on the stock market later this year. It calls AI “the most consequential technology in human history” (no surprises there) while also warning that it may pose “catastrophic or existential risks to humanity” – again, not particularly surprising given Anthropic’s public record, but it does raise eyebrows to see this language in documents filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission.

]]>
2596083
AI refutes 30-year-old mathematical assumption in computer science /article/2596045-ai-refutes-30-year-old-mathematical-assumption-in-computer-science/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Tue, 27 Oct 2026 15:28:44 +0000 /article/2596045-auto-draft/
OpenAI announced three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science and physics
Samuel Boivin/NurPhoto via Getty Images

OpenAI, the maker of ChatGPT, claims its AI models have disproven the exponential time hypothesis – a fundamental assumption that underpins computer science.

“This came as a complete surprise, a shock,” says at the University of Bergen in Norway. “Nobody I know expected it.”

Proposed nearly 30 years ago, the exponential time hypothesis (ETH) tries to put a limit on how quickly computers can solve certain logical puzzles.

The simplest way would be to try every possible combination of true or false for each part of the puzzle. ETH proposes that, although it may be possible to do this quicker with shortcuts, the amount of work needed has to grow exponentially as the puzzle gets bigger.

OpenAI, however, says its models have devised an algorithm that can beat the previously assumed speed limit for solving logical puzzles, apparently proving ETH false. “Assuming that it is confirmed, this is an enormous breakthrough,” says at the University of Oxford.

Many computer science findings assume ETH is true. If it isn’t, the conclusions they establish about computational limits become useless. “It would require a complete revision of several areas of algorithms and complexity,” says Fomin, who says a textbook he wrote on the subject would become obsolete if the finding holds.

ETH is linked to a long-standing maths problem known as P versus NP, which concerns whether a problem whose answer is easy to check is also easy to solve. If ETH were true, it would have implied that the answer was no. But disproving ETH wouldn’t mean the answer is yes. “This doesn’t have a direct impact on P versus NP, so we should not view it as progress towards P versus NP,” says Goldberg.

The result was announced alongside other breakthroughs in maths and physics on 26 October.

In mathematics, OpenAI says its AI has proved a 1991 conjecture that waves cannot remain intensely focused for long. If confirmed, this would also answer enduring questions about how thin a shape can be while also containing line segments that point in every direction, as well as how waves spread.

In theoretical physics, OpenAI claims to have proven that quantum field theories – including quantum chromodynamics, which describes the strong force holding quarks together – make sense mathematically, rather than just producing predictions that match experiments. The findings also touch on the existence of pure Yang–Mills theory, part of a million-dollar mathematical problem, but don’t resolve the entire challenge. That work hasn’t been released publicly while an external group led by Nobel laureate David Gross examines it.

OpenAI says it verified the ETH result using Lean, a piece of software that checks mathematical proofs. at TU Wien in Austria has looked at what OpenAI has released and says he expects it to withstand scrutiny, although he says researchers still need to check that the formally proven statement means what its authors say it means.

To do so, OpenAI has commissioned an independent group, including Russell Impagliazzo and Ramamohan Paturi, both at the University of California, San Diego, who helped propose ETH, to examine the findings. In , the group says it could “change an important part of theoretical computer science”.

The speed at which AI is solving maths problems and the way AI firms are releasing their findings have concerned some academics. at Royal Holloway, University of London, describes the phenomenon as “mathematics done by press”, worrying that proprietary models can suddenly overturn months of researchers’ work.

at the Eindhoven University of Technology in the Netherlands describes OpenAI’s work on ETH as “ingenious”, “spectacular” and “awe-inspiring – but also humbling.” “It really makes you think about the future of mathematics, algorithms and academia,” he says.

at the University of Sydney says proving something and understanding why it is true aren’t the same thing. “The web collapsed, and we looked behind,” he says of the network of findings relying on ETH. “We have no idea why yet.”

OpenAI says it is experimenting with an approach in which independent academics organise efforts to verify and explain the results. But Fomin welcomes the disruption. “This result destroys a lot, but it also opens many new opportunities and new questions that nobody expected,” he says. “One shouldn’t complain about having too many interesting mathematical breakthroughs to try to digest,” says Wahlström.

]]>
2596045
Robotic dog controlled with a computer powered by human blood cells /article/2594537-robotic-dog-controlled-with-a-computer-powered-by-human-blood-cells/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Mon, 26 Oct 2026 14:00:00 +0000 /article/2594537-auto-draft/ 2594537 Brazil presidential election dogged by alleged bias by Meta AI tools /article/2595540-brazil-presidential-election-dogged-by-alleged-bias-by-meta-ai-tools/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=ai&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Fri, 23 Oct 2026 13:58:34 +0000 /article/2595540-auto-draft/
Supporters of Lula protest at Meta’s headquarters in Dublin
Natalia Campos/Getty Images

A deluge of AI-generated content and unfair treatment by social media platforms could prove pivotal in Brazil’s presidential election, according to supporters of the left-wing incumbent Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.

Lula will face off against right-wing challenger Flávio Bolsonaro on 25 October in the second round of the contest. Lula’s campaign has Meta – which owns WhatsApp, Instagram and Facebook – of favouring Bolsonaro by suspending Lula’s campaign advertising account, suppressing posts and blocking AI-generated content.

Brazil’s electoral prosecutors have said with court orders to ensure equal treatment of both candidates, while United Nations human rights experts possible unequal treatment of the two campaigns.

Images have widely circulated showing Meta AI, a chatbot integrated into WhatsApp, refusing to generate campaign posters for Lula, while instantly producing an image for “Flávio”.

Meta said “claims that we are favoring or interfering on behalf of any candidate or political group are false and unfounded”. It said Lula’s account was suspended for 1 hour by mistake and that its systems blocked prompts referring to the names “Lula” and “Bolsonaro”, but not the common first names Luiz or Flávio.

Lula’s campaign remains unconvinced. It submitted screenshots to the electoral court showing Meta AI repeatedly assigning Bolsonaro’s electoral number, 22, to generic, fictional politicians and allegedly translating “Flávio futuro presidiário” (“Flávio future prisoner”) as “Flávio future president”.

Determining whether the discrepancies are deliberate is impossible because Meta’s systems are opaque, says at the University of Virginia. “But when a technical glitch tends to repeat its outcome, it’s very hard to accept that this is just a technical failure.”

Lula finished behind Bolsonaro in the first round of voting, but polls show the gap is narrowing. The comeback has been partly credited to Lula’s Army, an intensive online campaign in which 8 million WhatsApp channel subscribers receive daily tasks, such as posting photographs on Instagram posing with their fingers forming an L.

This year’s general election is Brazil’s first since large language models (LLMs) became widely popular, and it is awash with AI-generated content. Experts say Latin America’s largest democracy offers a glimpse of what is to come for AI in politics.

of AI-generated or manipulated election content ahead of the first round, primarily on Facebook and Instagram, 60 per cent of it unlabelled. found that 26 Meta advertising accounts appeared to sidestep restrictions on foreign-funded political advertising by posting AI-generated videos, including one depicting Bolsonaro and Argentina’s president Javier Milei freeing Brazil from communists.

Meta’s independent oversight board says the company’s .

“It’s very worrying,” says Nemer. “So much of our political campaign dynamics have been transferred to privatised companies that we have no idea how they operate.”

Regulating AI in political campaigns won’t be as simple as it seems, says at InternetLab, a Brazilian digital rights non-profit that studied how eight major AI chatbots respond to questions about Brazil’s election.

Its report found that chatbots sometimes refused genuine questions about candidates, referring users to official electoral websites, but would agree to draft misleading claims questioning the integrity of elections for use in campaigning.

Massaro says clearer safeguards for LLMs are needed, but first their objectives must be defined.

“Are the safeguards working? That’s one question. But working for what, because it depends on what your goals are,” she says. “Is the solution to send people away without providing any kind of information? Is this what we want?”

]]>
2595540