Hannah Fry, Author at New Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥ Science news and science articles from New Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥ Thu, 12 Nov 2026 09:36:26 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0.8 242057827 Hannah Fry: How to win The Traitors with maths (step one, don’t get made a traitor) /article/2597314-hannah-fry-how-to-win-the-traitors-with-maths-step-one-dont-get-made-a-traitor/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=currents&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Wed, 04 Nov 2026 14:00:00 +0000 /article/2597314-auto-draft/
Fran Pulido

In the late 1980s, in Soviet-era Russia, a young psychologist called Dmitry Davydov came up with a game about power and information. He called it Mafia and originally intended it as a teaching device, a way to demonstrate how a small, informed minority could manipulate the dynamics of a much larger, uninformed group and wield outsized power over those who were left floundering in uncertainty and paranoia.

Almost 40 years later, that game has evolved into – a TV show that is such a massive cultural phenomenon in the UK that the opening episode of this year’s celebrity edition than watched England’s World Cup semi-final against Argentina.

And recently I found myself in the middle of it.

In case you’ve been living under a rock, or just happen to have better things to do with your life than watch reality television (in which case, lucky you), the premise is simple. A small number of players, the traitors, secretly know who is on their side and get to “murder� someone each night. The remaining players, the faithful, are tasked with working out who the traitors are, voting to banish one suspect each evening. Inevitably, they spend most of their time rounding on innocent people and making them disintegrate. Which I strongly suspect might be at least half of what makes the whole thing so damn entertaining.

Here’s the thing. When I got the call asking if I wanted to be on the show, of course I jumped at the chance. A game of incomplete information? That’s a mathematician’s dream, I thought. What a fun, stress-free way to try out some of my theories.

On reflection, past me was an idiot. But we’ll come to that.

The challenge, as I saw it, was to find a way to cut through the uncertainty. All I had to do was monitor the evidence as the game unfolded, use the patterns in people’s behaviour to identify the traitors and then just persuade everyone else to vote them out. Bish bash bosh, victory.

I started by combing through every previous series of the UK show, turning the joyful, chaotic mess of the series into a clean, delicious spreadsheet, determined to use all the statistical tricks I had at my disposal. Who voted for whom? Who travelled in cars together? Were there subtle statistical differences in the way traitors and faithful behaved that might give the game away?

It turned out there were. For example, I discovered that traitors often make what I came to think of as “burn votes�. They don’t necessarily want to send down an innocent person, nor do they want to persuade others into joining a stampede, drawing attention to themselves in the process. So, instead, they throw their vote away on someone nobody else is voting for.

They will also vote to banish their fellow traitors, but only when the writing is already on the wall. Someone who suddenly joins the vote against a traitor on the night they are finally banished, having never voted for them before, was a signal worth keeping an eye on.

There were clues pointing in the other direction, too: failing to vote for a traitor on the night they are banished turned out to be a good signal that someone is faithful. And then there was a particularly ingenious observation made by viewers online: the producers often send the players who were shortlisted for murder into breakfast last. Occasionally, they throw one traitor into that group to keep everyone guessing, but never two. Which means that if someone arrived late to breakfast alongside a player who was subsequently revealed to be a traitor, that was a potentially useful clue that they were faithful.

Joanne McNally, Maya Jama, Julie Hesmondhalgh and Hannah Fry at breakfast in The Celebrity Traitors
From left: Joanne McNally, Maya Jama, Julie Hesmondhalgh and Hannah Fry at breakfast in The Celebrity Traitors
BBC/Studio Lambert/Euan Cherry

As far as I could tell, there were no surefire ways to identify someone as a traitor (although Richard E. Grant would later do a spectacular job of proving me wrong). The faithful are so gloriously unpredictable (ahem. Joanne McNally) that anything suspicious could almost as easily have been done by a perfectly innocent player. But even so, buried in the noise, there were some small signals that could accumulate over time.

Fortunately, there is a neat mathematical way to combine lots of weak evidence together – and it just so happens to have been used by Alan Turing to help crack the enigma code in the second world war. So, inspired by Turing, with a little help from our mutual, close personal friend Thomas Bayes, I set about building a Bayesian model that I could bring with me into the castle.

It’s actually pretty simple: a points system that lets you update the odds of someone being a traitor as you go. The scores came from what had happened in previous series, and are almost entirely based on people’s voting patterns. +0.47 for a burn vote. -0.83 if you fail to vote for a traitor on the night they go down.

For the nerdier among you, the units I was using are nats – a measure of how strongly the accumulated evidence favours one hypothesis over another – but you can just think of them as traitor points.

I was as confident as I could be that, at the very least, the famous words of statistician George E. P. Box would prove true: “All models are wrong, but some are useful.�

Unfortunately, there was one rather significant problem with my plan. Within about 15 minutes of arriving in the castle, they made me a traitor. (Technically I could have refused, but it happened in such a way that it would have meant my immediate downfall.)

I went back to my room and sobbed into my spreadsheets.

Still, I’m not about to let the small matter of being made a traitor (and catastrophically failing to be deceitful on national television) get in the way of a good mathematical experiment. So, now that the final has aired and I know the way that the votes fell, I can finally run the numbers to see how the model would have played out in real time.

And I’m delighted to say that the maths worked. Brilliantly, in fact. At every single round table, the maths has a traitor as top, or joint top. Not every innocent player escaped suspicion, and the model certainly wasn’t infallible. But there really are signals buried in that noise, and you really can use mathematics to detect them. (And yes, the irony that literally being buried is what got me into this mess is not lost on me).

The trouble is, a mathematical model has one enormous advantage over a contestant on The Traitors. It doesn’t have to convince anyone to trust it. It doesn’t have to worry about being murdered or defend itself against accusations over breakfast, while trying to remember what normal facial expressions look like. And so even if I’d been a faithful, I suspect there was never any realistic chance of putting the mathematics to use within the game itself. Because, as Mafia was designed to demonstrate, the real power in a game like this isn’t just knowing the truth, it’s being able to shape what everyone else believes.

And so, George, it turns out some models are right. It’s just that, sometimes, that’s the least of your problems.

]]>
2597314
Hannah Fry: I lost my dad to Alzheimer’s. New research into its origins is amazing /article/2595637-hannah-fry-i-lost-my-dad-to-alzheimers-new-research-into-its-origins-is-amazing/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=currents&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Wed, 28 Oct 2026 14:00:00 +0000 /article/2595637-auto-draft/
Fran Pulido

I was sitting in a conference in August, drifting as I so often do between listening to what was on stage and pretending to be doing important work on my laptop (by which I mean sending memes on WhatsApp).

All of a sudden, from the stage, the renowned biologist came out with a sentence that made every single person in the room sit up and pay attention: “Of course,â€� she said, “we now know that ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s starts in the nose.â€�

I’m sorry, what? Starts in the nose? I didn’t know ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s starts in the nose.

My own lovely dad died from ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s last year, and ever since his diagnosis, I’ve done an incredible amount of digging into the disease, trying to understand what was happening to him. I was astonished I’d never come across this idea.

And perhaps you haven’t either. Which is why I want to share my astonishment at discovering that Aviv Regev was right – not only is ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s closely associated with our sense of smell, but there is a growing body of research suggesting that our noses might have something to do with why the disease develops in the first place.

The first bit you might already know: people with ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s tend to lose their sense of smell, sometimes years before any symptoms of memory loss start to show up. But it turns out that our ability to smell is a surprisingly good indicator of our overall health (looking at you, covid-19). One study from 2014 found that of whether they would be dead within five years than a cancer diagnosis.

Could pollution find its way to the brain via smell receptors?
STEVE GSCHMEISSNER/Science Photo Library/Alamy

It’s not that losing your sense of smell itself will kill you. More that the olfactory nerves are deeply intertwined with some of the most important memory structures in the brain, so when they start to deteriorate, it can be an early warning that something much more serious is going on.

And this connection seems to work in both directions. One intriguing study (admittedly with quite a small sample size) , thus exposing them to all kinds of wonderful scents while they slept. After six months, the people who had the olfactory enrichment performed better on memory tests than those in a control group.

All very interesting. But not what Regev had been suggesting. Her words seemed to imply that noses are actually responsible for the trouble in the first place.

It turns out that the reason scientists are even entertaining this possibility is because of how fiercely our brains are protected from the outside world. Our skulls are like an actual fortress: even our blood isn’t allowed in without passing a particularly fussy bouncer called the blood-brain barrier.

One of the only real exceptions is a little bit of bone right at the top of your nose that is riddled with holes. It’s called the cribriform, and it’s where the olfactory fibres dangle down into your nose to give you your sense of smell – a bit like if you pushed some Play-Doh through a sieve.

And that means that, despite all the elaborate defences protecting your brain, there is a potential route in, sitting right in the middle of your face.

So, here’s the idea. Maybe the beta-amyloid plaques, the sticky little protein fragments that appear to play such a key role in the cascade of ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s in the brain, are what’s left over after the brain has fought an infection. And maybe the nose is how the infection arrives.

To see if this held any water, in 2022, a group of scientists of some mice.

(I should add, for the sake of the mice’s reputation, that it was actually Chlamydia pneumoniae, a cousin of the bacterium that causes the STI. But I hope you’ll forgive me the less scientifically accurate version. In a long career, you get very few chances to write sentences that good, and I wasn’t about to waste mine.)

The remarkable thing, though, was that within 72 hours, the bacteria had travelled up the nerves in the nasal cavity and got through to the brain. What’s more, the infection triggered the accumulation of beta-amyloid. Now that’s not definitive proof of how ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s starts in humans. But there is some other, rather unsettling evidence that infections aren’t the only unwelcome visitors that manage to get in that way.

A group in Mexico . Inside the dogs’ brains, they found microscopic particles of metals – that seem to have entered through the nose – wrapped in pockets of inflammation and that same beta-amyloid protein. You don’t see the same thing in dogs that lived in cleaner, more rural environments.

Now these studies have been extended to who died from gun violence or car accidents – and they find something similar. Tiny, metal–rich particles, thought to originate from exhausts and brake dust, turned up in their brain tissue, alongside inflammation and accumulations of beta-amyloid. The very sorts of changes associated with ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s, appearing in brains that were sometimes only a few years old. Put together, it implies that the disease might have an environmental cause, one that begins much much earlier than we thought.

So, where does ´¡±ô³ú³ó±ð¾±³¾±ð°ù’s start? The answer is no one nose (pun very much intended). There is still a great deal we don’t understand, but the implications from all this research are rather extraordinary. What if the beta-amyloid plaques we’ve spent so long trying to get rid of are, at least sometimes, the aftermath of the brain trying to protect itself? And what if, rather than focusing entirely on clearing up the damage, we could work out what set it off in the first place?

But more than anything, I can’t help but laugh as I think about all this in the context of my dad, who had many wonderful qualities, but a discreet nose wasn’t one of them. We used to say that his nose would enter a room 15 minutes before he did. He would have found it very funny indeed if it turned out to have been the cause of his downfall.

]]>
2595637
Hannah Fry: How OpenAI has caused an existential crisis in mathematics /article/2593249-hannah-fry-how-openai-has-caused-an-existential-crisis-in-mathematics/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=currents&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:00:00 +0000 /article/2593249-auto-draft/
Fran Pulido

A few years ago, when I first started talking about mathematics in public, a professor of algebraic number theory pulled me to one side and gave me some sharp words of warning: “The world fears mathematicians, Hannah. Let’s keep it that way.�

He was being, to put it mildly, a bit of a snob. Maths had an intimidating mystique to maintain, and I was apparently jeopardising it by titting around on the internet making videos and podcasts, rather than focusing on a perfectly respectable research career.

I have thought a lot about that comment since. Partly because I have spent the intervening years doing everything I can to completely ignore him (and getting a New Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥ column feels like a rather lovely reward for doing so).

But buried beneath his snobbery, I have come around to the idea that he was right about something. And I have never felt that more than in the past few weeks, since a swarm of AI agents have been busy solving our most famous long-standing problems.

I’m talking, of course, about OpenAI’s announcements over the past few weeks that it has found proofs for hundreds of mathematics problems that had previously resisted human attempts to solve them.

The furore began, most notably, with a proof (by way of finding a counterexample) that the Navier-Stokes equations can break apart. This particular gem was such a big deal to the mathematical community that at the turn of the millennium, the Clay Mathematics Institute promised they’d give $1 million to whoever managed to solve it.

Those Navier-Stokes equations are what I did my PhD on. They are basically Isaac Newton’s second law of motion: F=ma, but applied to fluids. They are, in my not entirely unbiased opinion, staggeringly beautiful, able to articulate everything from the drip of a water droplet on a leaf and the churn of an entire atmosphere to the gases swirling around in a galaxy in the sky.

The thing is, these equations have a tricky little bit that pops out of the acceleration part, which contains a feedback loop within it. The faster fluid flows, the faster the gradient can get between two adjacent streams, and so the faster fluid flows. It’s a bit like the fluid version of putting a microphone next to a speaker. The feedback loop can get louder and louder until everything ends up breaking. Or, in the case of the Navier-Stokes equations, the speed of the flow heads off to infinity.

To be clear: no one was ever worried about fluid dynamics tearing open a black hole when you stir your tea or anything. It was just that the weird behaviour of this little term left the possibility that the equations themselves would break.

On the flip side, there’s another term in the equation – the viscosity – that acts as a brake and calms everything down, stopping the flow from getting completely out of control. So, the question was: does the brake always kick in?

If you have been following the story, then by now you will know what happened. Various groups of mathematicians had been using AI to circle in on this problem, finding special cases where the feedback loop goes crazy, without quite getting to the full Navier-Stokes.

But supposedly, once OpenAI heard that others were getting close, they threw everything at it: 10,000 AI agents, sending each other 3 million messages over 88 hours, costing millions of dollars in tokens, to find a single example where everything blows up. The Navier-Stokes equations do indeed fall. And an AI proved it.

This should have been a glorious moment of scientific exposition, but instead, mathematicians have spent the last few weeks having a massive collective wobble.

Part of the reason is that nobody yet understands the answer. The OpenAI solution is almost hilariously ugly. It is a proof that’s 166 pages long, accompanied by hundreds of thousands of lines of formal code – almost impenetrable symbols – slapped down on the table and left for the mathematicians to pick apart, while the AI labs move on to the next thing. They came for the glory without giving much back.

So, we are left with a proof that almost no one wants to read, a $1 million prize that no one will want to , and no one who can stand at a blackboard and explain why this particular vortex makes everything break, when nothing else we tried ever did.

And now, to top it off, the new tranche of proofs that landed last week claim to have polished off hundreds of other important, unsolved mathematical problems, including a big result in the biggest trophy in all of mathematics: the Riemann Hypothesis. All tipped onto the code-sharing website GitHub for someone else to check.

So, mathematicians are having their own existential crisis about their role and purpose, like Lee Sedol did after AlphaGo, Gary Kasparov before him with Deep Blue and probably every literature graduate, musician and artist since ChatGPT was launched.

Please don’t get me wrong. I want to use this column, at least in part, to talk about the incredible, world-changing things that are happening with AI in science. I know that there is some inevitability to machines outpacing the humans, and I know that at its best, AI has a great deal to offer.

But at its worst, AI is an engine of extraction. Not just text, or images or equations. The real sting in the tail is that OpenAI set its sights on mathematics because the prestige, the respect and the glory was just another thing that could be mined.

It didn’t need to be that way.

They so easily could have been open and collaborative. But the moment when one of humanity’s greatest intellectual traditions became vulnerable, they chose conquest over stewardship.

And so, I am left thinking about that professor again. He was right that there is a special mystique to mathematics, but wrong about who would puncture it. And I’m sorry to say that, while the world might fear mathematicians, the machines certainly don’t.

]]>
2593249