Ä¢¹½Ö±²„

We all love Marie Kondo. So why is tidying up so hard?

The Japanese neatness consultant has inspired millions toĀ declutter. So why is getting your home Instagrammably neat so difficult, asks David H. Freedman
illustration of woman with neatly organised boxes in her head
Does an orderly mind follow an orderly home?
Josie Ford

A CLUTTER-free kitchen, living room or office resonates with a clean, graceful aesthetic. Neatness implies organisation and discipline. Stress and inefficiency disappear with stray socks and theĀ morning’s dishes. That’s the promise of Japanese neatness consultant Marie Kondo, as she espouses ā€œthe life-changing magic of tidying upā€ in her Netflix series.

Today, as rising housing costs and the appeal of urban living leave more people stuffed together in small apartments, aĀ certain level of tidiness can beĀ essential. Our social-media sharing exacerbates that demand. But why are so many of us obsessed by the idea of tidiness? Research sheds little light on theĀ question because virtually allĀ studies of neatness and organisation start by defining mess as dysfunctional.

There is little evidence that anyone without servants or similar help put a lot of effort intoĀ or worried much about tidiness before the 1950s. That suggests we have little innate drive towards neatness. Perhaps our modern admiration of the super-neat tookĀ root in the unrealistically sanitised homes of the faux families in early sitcoms and advertisements, just when the post-war boom era was enabling many people to accumulate ever more stuff. So now we either throw ourselves into the task of straightening up or feel guilty if we don’t. But whileĀ the benefits that attend tidiness feel obvious and get a lot of good PR, we don’t hear much about its costs.

Neatness requires an often considerable investment of resources: time, thought, physicalĀ effort, perhaps money for shelving and boxes, or for professional guidance. Tidying upĀ a mess is real work, and even once accomplished requires constant maintenance against theĀ tug of entropy.

I am well aware of the costs of neatness, having co-authored an entire book on it. But I have also discovered that few people do theĀ accounting when it comes toĀ making a rational, thoughtful decision about how much tidinessĀ might be enough, orĀ evenĀ too much.

People with messy desks told me they spent less time looking for documents than people with neat desks. That makes sense: theĀ most recent and oft-used documents tend to end up at theĀ top of piles, instead of being hidden away according to some complex, half‑forgotten filing scheme. Heaps of clothes work theĀ same way. Disorderly doesn’t mean disorganised.

So sure, feeling the urge to neaten up is reasonable and practical. But it is worth keeping inĀ mind that excessive tidiness can take a toll too, and a bit of clutter, seen the right way, can beĀ aĀ balm.

Read more:Ā Dishing the dirt: How clean does your home really need to be?;ĢżHow clean is too clean? The truth about hygiene and your health

Topics: Psychology