AS UNINTENDED consequences go, this would take some beating. Artificial sweeteners, used by millions of people as a healthier substitute for sugar, may actually cause diabetes.
That is the take-home message of a study out this week (see “Artificial sweeteners linked to glucose intolerance“) that will leave many consumers worried and confused – an understandable response, but also a premature one.
The new study does appear to ask serious questions and, if its conclusions hold up, health authorities will be duty bound to act. But we are still a long way from that. Although the research seems meticulous, the evidence comes from mice, plus a couple of small studies in humans – and different people responded differently. It only covers three sweeteners – saccharin, sucralose and aspartame – and only saccharin in detail. Many other widely used sweeteners were not included.
Advertisement
The cliché “more research needed� clearly applies here – as the researchers acknowledge. Given the public health implications, they and others are no doubt already on the case.
Admittedly, “more research needed� doesn’t add up to helpful advice for consumers. At this stage, though, it would be irresponsible to say anything else.
This article appeared in print under the headline “The sweetener question�