When the writer of an infamous book for hackers says we should stop panicking about cyberwar it’s probably time to sit up and take notice.
“Governments should take a calm, disciplined approach and evaluate the risks of each type of attack very carefully rather than be swayed by scare stories,� says Peter Sommer of the London School of Economics.
Under the pseudonym “Hugo Cornwall�, Sommer published the infamous Hacker’s Handbook in 1985. Since then he has become a noted security researcher and expert witness. Now he has co-authored a report for the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) which warns governments against swallowing wholesale stories about “cyberwar� and “cyberweapons�.
Advertisement
Published today, says that a true cyberwar would have the destructive effects of conventional war but be fought exclusively in cyberspace – and as such is a “highly unlikelyâ€� occurrence. Like others, New Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥ has often used the term.
Cyber-spying
“Analysis of cyber-security issues has been weakened by the lack of agreement on terminology and the use of exaggerated language,� the report says. “Cyber-espionage is not a few keystrokes away from cyberwar, it is a method of spying.�
Controversially, the OECD advises nations against adopting the Pentagon’s idea of setting up a military division – as it has under the auspices of the US air force’s Space Command – to fight cyber-security threats. While vested interests may want to see taxpayers’ money spent on such ventures, says Sommer, the military can only defend its own networks, not the private-sector critical networks we all depend on for gas, water, electricity and banking.
Co-authored with computer scientist Ian Brown of the Oxford Internet Institute, UK, the report says online attacks are unlikely ever to have global significance on the scale of, say, a disease pandemic or a run on the banks. But they say “localised misery and loss� could be caused by a successful attack on the internet’s routing structure, which governments must ensure are defended with investment in cyber-security training.
Jay Abbott, a security manager at the consultancy PricewaterhouseCoopers, agrees that the routing structure is indeed vulnerable. “Short of physically cutting the wires, it’s the best way to take down a country from the internet,� he says.