Whatever made Facebook think it would be a good idea to have 50 privacy settings with more than 170 options?
According to Gus Hosein, policy chief with the pressure group , the blame lies with a failure to think clearly about how users would respond to the system as it grew.
“They were making that mess up as they went along,� Hosein says. “They didn’t realise the human-computer interface (HCI) really matters.�
Advertisement
Rapid rewrite
The complexity of those privacy settings, compounded by company-enforced changes that overrode some user privacy choices, led to a storm of criticism from Facebook members. The company has responded with a rapid rewrite of its privacy controls.
Whether those changes will satisfy disgruntled users remains to be seen, but HCI shortcomings are not unique to Facebook. “It’s a problem for everyone involved in online self-publishing,� Anthony House, European policy manager at Google, told an Index on Censorship meeting in London last month.
Google made a major HCI blunder in February when it glued the Buzz social network onto its Gmail email service. Users who did not opt out when a Buzz introduction screen appeared found that they had become Buzz members – and that long-forgotten email contacts had become “friends�.
“We got that wrong and we learned from it,� says House. “We do need more intuitive human-computer interaction.�
To manage a concept as nuanced as privacy requires a back-to-basics approach to user interfaces, says , an HCI researcher at University College London. She was surprised to find that a picture she had posted on Facebook ended up searchable in Google Images.
Obscure settings
When Blandford investigated, she found that the meaning of many privacy settings was obscure – something that HCI specialists strive to avoid. Such specialists should be part of every design team from the very start, Blandford says.
Ideally there should be a way to preview your social site as if you were a stranger, a friend, or a friend-of-a-friend – something akin to an out-of-body experience at the desktop, Blandford says. “I want to log in as someone else and look at my online profile to see what I can see of myself.�
“That’s a brilliant idea,� says Hosein. “And it wouldn’t be too challenging to implement, either.�