Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥

Stupidity should be cured, says DNA discoverer

Fifty years to the day from the discovery of the structure of DNA, James Watson causes a furore

Fifty years to the day from the discovery of the structure of DNA, one of its co-discoverers has caused a storm by suggesting that stupidity is a genetic disease that should be cured.

On 28 February 1953 biologists James Watson and Francis Crick discovered the structure of DNA – the chemical code for all life. The breakthrough revealed how genetic information is passed from one generation to the next and revolutionised biology and medicine.

But in a documentary series to be screened in the UK on Channel 4, Watson says that low intelligence is an inherited disorder and that molecular biologists have a duty to devise gene therapies or screening tests to tackle stupidity.

“If you are really stupid, I would call that a disease,� says Watson, now president of the Cold Spring Harbour Laboratory, New York. “The lower 10 per cent who really have difficulty, even in elementary school, what’s the cause of it? A lot of people would like to say, ‘Well, poverty, things like that.’ It probably isn’t. So I’d like to get rid of that, to help the lower 10 per cent.�

Watson, no stranger to controversy, also suggests that genes influencing beauty could also be engineered. “People say it would be terrible if we made all girls pretty. I think it would be great.�

Complex traits

But other scientists have questioned both the ethics and plausibility of his suggestions.

Nikolas Rose, a bioethics expert at the London School of Economics, says such genetic engineering may not be possible: “These are complex traits, with multiple genes interacting with the environment.�

“These are characteristically casual and provocative statements by James Watson,� Rose adds. “I think they should be treated just as amusing rather than as a serious account of what behavioural genetics or any genetics should be doing, or will be able to do.�

Geneticist Steve Jones, at University College London, dismisses Watson’s comments about beauty as “daftâ€�. “The concept of beauty is a subjective one,â€� he told New Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥.

No fool

But he adds: “The IQ suggestion is a little bit less silly, if you turn the logic on its head. Watson likes to annoy – no question – but he’s no fool.� Genetics could and does help people with severe disorders like Fragile X syndrome and phenylketonuria, both of which affect IQ, says Jones: “The problem is where do we draw the line?�

Series producer David Dugan, of Windfall Films, said the programmes also show Watson visiting a family who greatly value their child with Down’s syndrome, as well as their child without Down’s.

“We were keen to confront Jim with this – he was genuinely moved,� but insisted that geneticists should work to eliminate the disorder. Dugan believes Watson’s views emanate from his own family’s experiences with his son, who has a mental illness resembling schizophrenia.

DNA begins in the UK on 8 March on Channel 4.

Read more: The truth about intelligence: A guide for the confused; Exclusive: A new test can predict IVF embryos’ risk of having a low IQ