“DEAR diary. Worrying news today. I read in a magazine that people who keep diaries are more likely to suffer from headaches, sleeplessness, digestive problems and even social dysfunction…�
That is the conclusion of a study by UK researchers Elaine Duncan of the Glasgow Caledonian University and David Sheffield of Staffordshire University. They compared 94 undergraduates who were regular diarists with 41 non-diarists. The volunteers filled in standard questionnaires about their health.
“We expected diary-keepers to have some benefit, or be the same, but they were the worst off,� says Duncan, who presented the findings to a British Psychological Society meeting in Edinburgh this week. “You are probably much better off if you don’t write anything at all.�
Advertisement
Because the study looked at existing diarists, it is not clear whether keeping a diary makes people less healthy or if less healthy people are more likely to keep a diary. But the findings are surprising because other studies suggest that people find it easier to recover from a traumatic event if they write about it.
One possibility, Duncan says, is that keeping a diary makes people dwell on their misfortunes. “It’s probably better not to get caught in a ruminative, repetitive cycle,� she says. She hopes to do further studies to see if writing about positive or negative things, makes a difference.