Ä¢¹½Ö±²¥

Defective argument

Eugenics is a dirty word that conjures up disturbing images of a dark
Victorian past. Eugenicists were convinced that societal ills such as poverty
and prostitution were simply the result of bad heredity—and that a smart
society would prevent such people from breeding. The movement began in the late
19th century, after Charles Darwin mooted the idea of natural selection. It was
Darwin’s cousin, Francis Galton, who coined the term “eugenics�, meaning “the
science of producing sound offspring�—which could mean anything from
encouraging healthy, bright people to have more children, to sterilising
“defectives�. Galton realised that working out how traits were inherited would
be more difficult in humans than in sweet peas, but that didn’t stop him from
³Ù°ù²â¾±²Ô²µâ€”s±ð±ð www.tsd.jcu.edu.au/hist/stats/galton.

Not everyone is satisfied that the eugenics movement is dead and buried.
The DNA Learning Center at the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, New York, has just
posted over a thousand photographs and documents chronicling the American
eugenics movement at http://vector. cshl.org/eugenics. The aim is to get people
thinking about “similarities between eugenics and our current preoccupation with
the implications of the Human Genome Project.� But be warned: the site is far
from gentle. It includes “defective� family trees and numerous calls for the
forced sterilisation of “orphans, ne’er-do-wells, tramps, the homeless and
±è²¹³Ü±è±ð°ù²õâ€�.

l These days, we can detect unwanted genes in single cells taken from very
early human embryos and decide whether or not to implant them. Take the case
(www.nhgri.nih.gov/About_NHGRI/Dir/Ethics/pre.html) of the couple screening an
embryo for severe combined immune deficiency, in which sufferers often need bone
marrow transplants to survive. The couple already have a daughter with SCID. But
not only do they want to make sure their next child doesn’t suffer from it, they
also want its bone marrow to be compatible with the older child, so it can be a
donor. The levels of ethical complexity rapidly become mind-boggling.

Topics: Internet