AN INDEPENDENT statistician has dealt a fresh blow to the credibility of
experiments that questioned the safety of genetically modified food.
Graham Horgan of Biomathematics and Statistics Scotland (BioSS) took another
look at data compiled by Arpad Pusztai, a biochemist who used to work at the
Rowett Research Institute in Aberdeen. Pusztai claimed that potatoes engineered
to produce a lectin, a type of protein, caused abnormal development of internal
organs and immune suppression in rats
(This Week, 20 February, p 4).
Lynne Jones, Labour MP for Birmingham, Selly Oak, revealed Horganās
conclusions at a hearing of the House of Commons Science and Technology
Committee on 8 March. āNo consistent pattern of changes in organ weights was
discernible,ā Jones told the committee.
Advertisement
Horganās reanalysis was commissioned by Pusztai himself, who also gave
evidence at this weekās hearings. But he seems to have drawn a different
conclusion from Horganās work. The studies āhave now been fully verified by
independent statistical analysisā, says his written evidence to the
committee.
Ron Kempton, director of BioSS, supports the conclusions described by Jones.
āThereās too much fog and background variation to pull out any systematic
effects,ā he says.
Data still to come may help to resolve the controversy. Stanley Ewen of the
University of Aberdeen, who examined the guts of Pustzaiās rats, has submitted
his work for publication in a peer-reviewed journal.