Belief in God in an Age of Science by John Polkinghorne, Yale University
Press, £14.95/$18, ISBN 0300072945
FOR particle physicist John Polkinghorneāthe only ordained member of
the Royal Societyā science and theology are not at loggerheads. They are
instead attempts to formulate coherent and adequate accounts of the phenomena
within their purview. The four Terry Foundation Lectures from which this book
grew add up to an invitation to a dialogue between adherents of both.
Why is our Universe so friendly to life and to mind? Polkinghorne builds his
answer on the anthropic principle. This holds that the values we observe for
various fundamental constantsāfrom the charge on an electron to the number
of dimensions of space-timeāare what they are because they are the values
which produce a universe hospitable to observers, like us. Small changes would
give a universe with no atoms, or no planets, and no observers. From this
near-tautology Polkinghorne argues that either there is a God, setting the
values, or there are many varied universes. He argues that the many-universes
model of quantum observation does not fulfil the requirement that the universes
be varied.
Advertisement
Polkinghorneās argument for the proposition that God is real is cogent and
his evidence is elegant. Natural theology once looked naively to nature for
examples of Godās craft. Polkinghorneās critical-realist theology, by contrast,
rests on a metaphysically pleasing bedrock: the fact that the Universe is
amenable to mathematical treatmentsāwhich is, once you think about it,
quite surprisingāespecially āprovides a powerful encouragement to . . .
embrace a generous view of the mental/material nature of realityā.
To demonstrate that the God this implies is āworthy of worship and the ground
of hopeā is Polkinghorneās most daunting task. Confronting the problem of evil,
he has to tackle nothing less than the nature of time. He cites the Universeās
āfreedom to becomeā, manifested in our consciousness as free will. If God is
atemporalāoutside past and future and aware of bothāthen our free
will is (from her/his/its point of view) actually mere ignorance of the future.
God must, he concludes, be unable to prevent misery and atrocity, and must
suffer the future as we do. He resolves the conflict between Godās omniscience
and failure to prevent woe by proposing that there is no future to be aware of,
even for an omniscient entity.
But God must also act. Here Polkinghorne turns to the mathematics of chaos:
ProvidenceāGod as caretakerāis to him a dynamic system of
nano-energic mathematical transactions. Citing the work of the chemist Ilya
Prigogine (Review, 6 September 1997), Polkinghorne postulates that ānew causal
principles may be held to be operating, which determine the pattern of future
behaviour and which are of a holistic characterā.
Particularly enticing for an argumentative reader are the passages concerning
the appearance of notions of value. āI cannot believe,ā Polkinghorne writes,
āthat [value] simply came into being when hominid brains had acquired sufficient
complexity to accommodate such thoughts.ā His proposal that our ancestors
recognised something that was there from the beginning leads him onto extremely
risky ground.
This book, refreshingly, is not an apology for Polkinghorneās Christian
faith. God is more than a cypher for the rational order of the Universe: āThat
was Einsteinās God,ā he says, splendidly robust, ābut it is certainly not
³¾¾±²Ō±š.ā
His is a rational and humane enquiry into phenomena which, by
epistemological necessity, resist scientific method. In this, his inquiry shares
much with the current debate around consciousnessāa debate he must now
engage in with some urgency.