THE MUSIC industry’s masterplan to deter home CD copying is in tatters this
week, following the discovery of a technical flaw in CD recorders which allows
copyright material on CDs to be copied onto cheap blank CD-ROMs.
To deter home CD copying, the major record companies persuaded Philips and
Sony to ensure that consumer CD recorders could only record on £5 blank
CDs, rather than on what initially were identical CD-ROM blanks costing
£1. So a technical difference was deliberately introduced in the
manufacturing process to ensure that CDs and CD-ROMs are not identical.
Blank music CDs are coated with a chemical dye that deforms into spots when
irradiated by the laser in a CD recorder. The blank disc is also embossed with a
spiral groove which acts as an optical guide for the laser as it makes the
recording. The groove wobbles from side to side, for use as a reference when
calculating the running time of recordings.
Advertisement
When Philips and Sony set the standard for recordable CDs they introduced a
small difference between the wobble on music CD blanks and CD-ROM blanks. When
a disc is loaded into a consumer recorder, the laser scans the disc and checks
the wobble type. If the disc is a blank CD, the audio recorder is ready to copy
a pre-recorded CD. If the wobble signature tells the recorder that the disc is a
CD-ROM it will be ejected.
At least, that was the theory. The strategy has now backfired: copyright
music can now be recorded on cheap blank CD-ROMs, making home copying a far
more economic proposition.
The flaw in the system was discovered by a reviewer at Home Cinema
Choice magazine, which publishes details in its July issue. The reviewer,
testing CD recorders from market leader Philips, has found a way of tricking
them into recording onto CD-ROM blanks.
The trick involves a simple manual manipulation of the CD recorder, which
fools the device’s wobble-reading mechanism into authorising recording on a
cheap blank CD-ROM. The simplicity of the copying trick has shocked the music
industry’s trade bodies.
A spokesperson for The International Federation of the Phonographic
Industries
says: “This reinforces our argument that music producers need good
protection… If this is a design flaw in the recorder, we are sure Philips will
put it right.�
But Philips says: “We are aware of this issue. It has now been picked up in
other countries where the players are sold. We have yet to decide how to tackle
¾±³Ù.â€�
But Philips’ options are limited as the mass-produced £400 CD recorders
have been on sale around the world for many months. Demand is now increasing as
consumers discover how cheap it is to record onto blank CD-ROMs.
The Mechanical Copyright Protection Society says the new-found ease of CD
copying is now an issue of “major concern� to its members. But the British
Phonographic Industry, trade body for the record companies, warns that home
recording of any copyright material remains an illegal act in Britain.