HARDCORE āgreensā are the only consumers who stick to their guns when it
comes to boycotting ethically dubious foods. Outside this extremely committed
core of individuals, most boycotters who claim to be green relapse into their
former buying habits once an issue fades from the headlines.
āThese fads tend to be short-lived, and people just drift back into buying
whatever they were boycotting,ā says Lynda Morris of the Leatherhead Food
Research Association, who has investigated the behaviour of consumers with a
conscience. She quizzed some forty people who described themselves as āethicalā
consumers.
She found that people fell into three categories. āConfirmedā, or hardcore,
ethical shoppers were typically vegetarians who bought free-range eggs and
organic produce, and belonged to environmental or animal welfare groups. Less
committed were the ācost-consciousā ethical shoppers who allowed their
conscience to influence their buying habits when they could afford it or during
scares about food safety. The least committed were the ācouch thinkersā, who
sympathised with ethical causes but were too apathetic to make a personal
stand.
Advertisement
Most of those interviewe during Morrisās survey had at some time boycotted
food products, particularly tuna that was not certified as ādolphin friendlyā.
French products such as wine and Golden Delicious apples were widely targeted
too, most recently in protest at the countryās nuclear tests in the Pacific.
Other boycotts included those of South African produce during the apartheid
years, Argentinian corned beef during the Falklands War, and produce from Norway
in protest against that countryās refusal to stop whaling.
Concern about animal welfare was the most common reason for boycotting
products, particularly veal, after the wide media coverage of protests against
veal crates, and Canadian fish, in protest at seal clubbing. Other issues, such
as political oppression or pollution of the environment, had less impact on
consumersā choice of food.
Nor were people prepared to take a sustained moral stand on exploitation of
cheap labour in developing countries, although there was general awareness that
the wages of workers on coffee plantations were low, for example. Very few
people had heard of CafƩ Direct or Traidcraft coffee, brands from sources
where workers are paid fair wages.
In ratings of companies, NestlƩ, the Swiss-based food giant, came in
for particular criticism because of reports that it discouraged breastfeeding in
the developing world by aggressively promoting its milk products. By almost
every measure of ethical practice, the Linda McCartney food company was most
highly rated.
Morris says that in the light of the findings, companies should try to steer
clear of unethical practices that could unleash a consumer backlash. But, given
the fickleness of most boycotters, āfirms shouldnāt lose sleep over itā, she
says.