THE prominent British virologist responsible for the controversial āscorpion gene experimentsā lost his job last week, although the experiments are likely to continue. At a meeting early last week, John Krebs, chief executive of the Natural Environment Research Council, offered David Bishop ācompulsory early redundancyā from his post as director of the Institute of Virology and Environmental Microbiology in Oxford. Bishop was ordered to clear his desk by 5 pm on Friday.
Krebs says the decision had ānothing whatsoeverā to do with the protests over Bishopās experiments with genetically engineered viruses. Bishop increased the killing power of viruses that attack caterpillar pests by giving them a gene for scorpion venom. His aim was to develop viral ābiopesticidesā that would be less damaging to the environment than chemical pesticides. Environmentalists and people living near the site of the experiment protested about the trials, arguing that the viruses could spread to a nearby nature reserve and harm the caterpillars of endangered moths (āWill the scorpion gene run wild?ā, New Ä¢¹½Ö±²„, 25 June 1994).
Krebs says that following an independent review of the instituteās work, the council decided to change its āmissionā to make its work more relevant to industry and to investigate the biodiversity of microorganisms. āThe conclusion was that in order to really refocus the programme we would need different leadership,ā says Krebs.
Advertisement
Bishop claims that the revised mission is virtually indistinguishable from the existing one, and that the programme of work under his directorship satisfied its requirements. He called the decision āprecipitate and unwarrantedā. Krebs has appointed Pat Nuttall, a specialist in tick-borne diseases, as acting director of the institute.
According to Krebs, the experiments with the genetically engineered viruses will continue.
George McGavin, assistant curator of entomological collections at the Oxford University Museum and a prominent opponent of Bishopās work, says: āIf the experiments continue, Iāll continue my opposition.ā